Traditional insurance transfers risk to an independent insurer that sets the price, writes the terms and keeps any underwriting profit. Captive insurance places that risk in a licensed insurance company owned by the business or group it insures, so the owners control coverage, pricing and claims handling and can keep the profit from good loss experience — in exchange for committing capital and retaining more of their own losses.
Who owns the insurer?
With traditional insurance, a business buys a policy from an insurer owned by outside shareholders or policyholders at large. With a captive, the insured is the owner. The NAIC describes a captive as a wholly owned subsidiary that insures its non-insurance parent and calls captives “essentially a form of self-insurance whereby the insurer is owned wholly by the insured.” Group and cell structures extend the same idea to several unrelated companies; our note on group captive vs. cell captive explains the difference. For the basics of how a captive is set up, start with what captive insurance is and how it works.
How is the premium set?
A traditional premium is priced from an insurer’s view of a whole class of businesses, plus its overhead and profit. Workers’ Compensation’s Captives 101 overview notes that traditional premiums can run higher because of the insurer’s overhead, while a captive can price around the owner’s own risks. A company with better-than-average losses stops subsidizing the average.
What happens to underwriting profit?
In a traditional policy, if claims come in below expectations, the insurer keeps the difference. In a captive, that underwriting profit — and investment income on reserves — can be retained by the owners. The reverse is also true: when losses run high, the owners absorb more of them, within the layer the captive retains.
Who controls claims and coverage?
A traditional insurer decides policy wording and manages claims. Captive owners influence coverage terms, pricing and claims handling directly, and they can insure risks the commercial market will not. Because owners bear the results, they tend to invest more in safety and loss control.
What does the captive owner give up?
- Capital and commitment. A captive is a regulated insurer subject to reporting, capital and reserve requirements in its domicile, and more than 70 jurisdictions have captive laws.
- Volatility. Retained losses hit the captive first; reinsurance is used to cap catastrophic exposure, as IQ-EQ notes.
- Administration. Managers, actuaries, auditors and a board add cost and time.
Which one is right?
Most companies use both: traditional insurance for catastrophic or volatile risk, and a captive for the predictable layer they can manage. The NAIC cites AM Best’s count of about 8,000 captives worldwide, up from roughly 1,000 in 1980 — evidence that ownership has moved well beyond the Fortune 500. Whether it fits depends on your losses, cash flow and appetite for control. Our guide, is a captive right for your business, walks through the test, and our 4-Step Strategic Process — Strategic Discovery, Risk Assessment, Solution Design and Ongoing Optimization — is how we help owners decide.