← Back to Torch Briefings

Is Captive Insurance a Good Idea?

Published by Ryan Mefford | November 19, 2026 | Part of the Torch Briefings series

Captive insurance is a good idea for a company with stable, predictable losses, the capital to fund an insurer, and leadership willing to manage it for years. For those companies it can lower the long-run cost of risk and give control over coverage and claims. For a business with volatile losses, thin capital or a short horizon, it usually is not.

Why do companies form captives?

The NAIC describes a captive as a wholly owned subsidiary created to provide insurance to its non-insurance parent, formed to meet the specific risk-management needs of its owners. Karin Landry of Spring Consulting Group, writing for Captive.com in July 2026, lists the practical reasons:

Do captives actually perform?

The rated segment suggests they can. AM Best data summarized by Risk & Insurance in 2025 showed rated captives averaging an 88.0 combined ratio over five years, against 97.0 for the commercial casualty composite. In July 2026, AM Best estimated that rated captives kept about $8.2 billion for their parent organizations over five years that would otherwise have gone to commercial insurers.

Those are results for established, rated captives. They are not a forecast for a new one.

When is a captive not a good idea?

Landry is just as direct about the downside. The parent must fund formation costs and the capital its domicile requires. Owners take on underwriting, claims and loss control, which takes time, people and management attention. Reinsurers can react faster to poor results than a commercial market might. And a merger or change in strategy can put a captive into run-off, producing cost with no current benefit. She also cautions that tax benefits should never be the main reason to form one.

How can you tell whether you are a candidate?

If those describe your company, a feasibility study is the right next step. Our guide to whether a captive is right for your business walks through it, and our briefings on how captive insurance works and captive vs. traditional insurance cover the basics.

At Peoples First Tennessee, we approach captives through our 4-Step Strategic Process: Strategic Discovery, Risk Assessment, Solution Design and Ongoing Optimization. The goal is an honest answer, including when the answer is no.

Explore the PFTN Network

Captive insurance knowledge and expertise across multiple industries and sectors:

PFTN Risk

Risk management and captive insurance foundations

Contractors PFTN

Captives for construction and trade contractors

GovCon PFTN

Captive solutions for government contractors

Nonprofit PFTN

Risk management strategies for nonprofits and associations